“Business Strategy or Price-Fixing?” DRAM Class Action Against Three Memory Makers Drags On, With Broader Antitrust Debate Over Key Industrial Inputs Expected
Authored On
Modified
Motion to dismiss DRAM price-fixing class action against Samsung Electronics, SK hynix and Micron denied Three memory makers cite “independent business decisions”; market observers also urge caution on expanding supply Possible debate over tighter scrutiny of industrial inputs with monopolistic or oligopolistic supply chains, including Chinese rare earths and LCDs

The class action involving Samsung Electronics, SK hynix and Micron shows little sign of reaching a conclusion. The plaintiffs allege that the three companies effectively pursued a joint strategy to raise prices, while the suppliers counter that their actions reflected independent business decisions and that there is no direct evidence of collusion. Amid the continuing dispute, market observers suggest that the lawsuit’s outcome could lead to tighter antitrust scrutiny not only of DRAM but also of markets for other key industrial inputs, such as rare earths and LCDs, where a small number of suppliers wield pricing power.
DRAM Collusion Lawsuit Against Three Memory Makers Continues
According to U.S. legal news outlet LitNews on the 14th (all dates hereafter are local time), Judge Noël Wise of the San Jose division of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California denied a joint motion by Samsung Electronics, SK hynix and Micron to dismiss the class action. She had reserved judgment after hearing 27 minutes of arguments from attorneys for both sides at a hearing on the 13th, but subsequently issued a written order finding that the plaintiffs’ collusion allegations had sufficiently specific grounds for the case to proceed. The court ordered the defendant companies to file their answers by December 7 and scheduled the first case management conference for January 12 next year.
The dispute began on June 25, when 17 plaintiffs, including individual consumers and small and medium-sized businesses from five U.S. states, filed a class action. The plaintiffs alleged that Samsung Electronics, SK hynix and Micron, which together account for more than 91% of global DRAM market revenue, had artificially restricted commodity DRAM supply and driven up prices since October 2022. Specifically, they said SK hynix announced capital spending reductions and production cuts for some products on October 26, 2022, followed by Micron on November 16 that year and Samsung Electronics on April 7 the following year. Samsung Electronics drew particular criticism for reversing its previous strategy of maintaining output even during industry downturns and taking steps similar to those of its competitors.
HBM Output Increases and Commodity DRAM Cuts Challenged
The plaintiffs also identified the three companies’ shift toward high-bandwidth memory (HBM) production as coordinated action to restrict supply. They argued that, as the companies concentrated production facilities and investment funds on HBM from 2023, the supply of memory used in ordinary PCs and servers declined. They noted that HBM requires approximately 3–4 times as much wafer area as DDR5 of the same capacity, meaning that allocating more production capacity to HBM reduces the capacity available to supply commodity DRAM. Samsung Electronics and SK hynix’s scaling back of DDR3 production lines from 2024, along with all three companies’ announcements between April and June last year of plans to phase out DDR4 production, were also cited as grounds for suspecting supply restrictions.
Another central issue is the lack of a meaningful expansion in production capacity amid surging prices. According to data presented in the plaintiffs’ complaint, global commodity DRAM prices soared approximately 697% over the 18 months from the end of the third quarter of 2024 to the end of the most recent first quarter. Quarterly contract prices also rose approximately 50%, 93% and 58%, respectively, from the fourth quarter of last year through the most recent second quarter. The plaintiffs allege that, despite this boom, the three companies focused on HBM investment while delaying existing factory construction plans or limiting the expansion of commodity DRAM production facilities. Other circumstances cited as supporting supply control included the companies’ introduction of similar order-screening procedures since January to check customers’ end buyers, order volumes and actual demand, as well as Micron’s decision to exit its Crucial consumer memory business.
Three Companies Stress Lack of Evidence of Collusion
Samsung Electronics, SK hynix and Micron, meanwhile, categorically deny the collusion allegations. In their joint motion to dismiss filed in September and a supplemental brief submitted last month, the three companies argued that reducing commodity DRAM production was an independent business decision responding to changes in market demand. They explained that each company adjusted output in light of the market downturn from the second half of 2022, then concentrated production capacity on HBM as growth in the artificial intelligence (AI) industry increased its demand and profitability. They also maintained that their production cuts occurred at different times and that HBM investment expansion and the discontinuation of DDR4 production followed company-specific schedules, making it difficult to characterize these moves as coordinated action.
The companies also pointed out that the plaintiffs had failed to present direct evidence of collusion between them. They argued that there was no specific evidence of meetings, communications or exchanges of confidential information to coordinate output or prices, and that competitors in an oligopolistic market can make similar decisions in response to the same market conditions. They added that, having already invested substantial funds in HBM production facilities and signed supply contracts with customers, they could not immediately shift production capacity back simply because commodity DRAM prices had risen.
Table 1. Arguments by Plaintiffs and Defendants in the DRAM Collusion Class Action Against Three Memory Makers
| Issue | Plaintiffs | Samsung Electronics, SK hynix and Micron |
|---|---|---|
| Commodity DRAM production cuts | The three companies jointly controlled supply and prices through successive production cuts | Independent business decisions responding to a market downturn, with cuts made at different times |
| Shift to HBM production | Increased HBM production intentionally reduced capacity available for commodity DRAM | A rational shift in product mix in response to growing AI demand and profitability |
| Scaling back DDR3 and DDR4 | Plans to discontinue older DRAM production were concentrated around similar periods | Pursued independently according to each company’s production schedule and business strategy |
| Prices and capital spending | Expansion of commodity DRAM production capacity delayed despite surging prices | Existing HBM investments and customer contracts make a rapid shift to commodity DRAM production difficult |
| Proof of collusion | Similar actions, including the introduction of order-screening procedures, support suspicions of coordinated conduct | No direct evidence of coordination on output or prices |
Industry Uncertainty Constrains Capital Spending
Some market analysts attribute delays in memory makers’ capacity expansion to uncertainty over industry conditions. The three memory makers previously experienced severe business difficulties from the second half of 2022 through 2023 because of plummeting demand and oversupply. In 2023, Samsung Electronics’ Device Solutions (DS) division posted a massive operating loss of USD 11.5 billion, while SK hynix recorded an operating loss of USD 5.95 billion. Although earnings began to show a visible recovery from 2024, the industry remains wary of a recurrence of heavy losses caused by oversupply. Indeed, in its April earnings announcement, SK hynix said it considers medium- to long-term demand visibility and investment efficiency when determining capital spending levels.
The substantial time required to establish new production facilities also constrains supply expansion. According to the U.S.-based Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), building a new DRAM plant, installing equipment, validating processes and ramping up stable production typically takes 2–3 years or more. This means that even if an expansion were approved immediately, the actual increase in supply could be delayed until 2028 or later. One market expert noted, “If new production facilities begin coming fully online in 2028–2029, supply growth could outpace demand growth depending on industry conditions,” adding, “Expanding capital spending based solely on the current supply shortage and rising prices carries the risk of facing oversupply and falling prices again, as in the past.”
Will the Need for Stronger Antitrust Regulation Come Into Focus?
The lawsuit could also broaden the debate over pricing power in supply chains for critical materials and components. China is a prominent example. It has gained control over supply chains for major industrial inputs and exerted considerable influence on global manufacturing through export restrictions and production adjustments. Last year, China’s rare earth export controls disrupted raw material procurement for the U.S. and European automotive and defense industries. More recently, Chinese companies including BOE, TCL CSOT and HKC, which account for approximately 70% of global LCD panel supply for televisions, have pursued production cuts and price increases, raising costs for finished-product manufacturers such as Samsung Electronics and LG Electronics.
Although the United States has expressed dissatisfaction with China’s control over supply chains for these critical materials and components, it has remained cautious in its response, taking into account its dependence on China and the possibility of trade retaliation. However, if the DRAM collusion lawsuit raises broader concerns about industrial structures in which a handful of companies control market supply, substantive debate could emerge within the United States over strengthening antitrust scrutiny of key industrial input markets through measures such as the Sherman Antitrust Act. The U.S. Sherman Antitrust Act prohibits price-fixing among competitors and agreements to restrict output, and provides that foreign companies may also be subject to regulation if such conduct affects commerce within the United States.