Slow Talent Development and Aging Systems Leave Japanese Companies’ Cyber Defenses in Crisis
Authored On
Modified
Cyberattacks halt orders and shipments, deepening revenue losses Security staff shortages delay normalization despite urgent recovery efforts Rising investment costs and mounting business losses add to corporate burdens

A succession of cyberattacks is disrupting Japanese businesses and fueling concerns about weaker consumer spending, weighing on the economic recovery. Suspended orders and shipments continue to hamper operations, while fears of personal data leaks could also discourage online transactions. Yet companies that rely heavily on outsourcing IT work are struggling to respond because they lack in-house security staff and have been slow to replace aging systems. Although the government is working to expand the security workforce, an aging population, inadequate retraining and limited capacity to train specialists make it difficult to ease staffing shortages on the ground. Companies now face the prospect of pouring money into overdue security investments and talent development while also absorbing business losses incurred in the meantime.
Four Hacked Companies Lose JPY 154.2 Billion in Revenue
According to Jiji Press on the 16th (all dates hereafter are local time), an analysis found that recent cyberattacks targeting Japanese companies could not only cause revenue losses from suspended orders and shipments but also dampen consumption by heightening fears of personal data leaks. Takahide Kiuchi, executive economist at Nomura Research Institute, estimated that four affected companies—Kadokawa, Asahi Group Holdings, Askul and Nichirei—suffered a combined JPY 154.2 billion decline in revenue, resulting in JPY 55.68 billion in lost gross domestic product (GDP). The estimate covers only companies with confirmed revenue losses and excludes subsequent losses from data leaks and deteriorating consumer sentiment. Kiuchi warned that economic damage could grow as consumers worried about personal data leaks shy away from online transactions. The concern is that customer defections could compound revenue losses caused by suspended orders and shipments.
Additional losses from cyberattacks pose a considerable burden on Japan’s economy, where consumption is already weak. According to figures released by Japan’s Cabinet Office on the 16th, real GDP in the third quarter of this year fell 0.02% from the previous quarter, or 0.1% on an annualized basis, marking the first contraction in four quarters. Private consumption, which accounts for more than half of GDP, fell 0.3% quarter on quarter, exposing the fragility of domestic demand. High prices increased living costs, heavy rain and typhoons restricted outings, and demand for cars and air conditioners slowed after rising in the previous quarter. The extent to which cyberattacks contributed to the contraction has not been separately established. However, concerns about further damage are growing because, with household purchasing power already weakened, a broader reluctance to transact over fears of personal data leaks would create another obstacle to a consumption recovery.
Ransomware Victims Face an Average 36-Day Business Interruption
Revenue losses are already accumulating at companies as restoring normal operations after an attack takes considerable time. A survey in Japan released by cybersecurity firm Trend Micro in August estimated that ransomware caused an average business interruption of about 36 days. The figure was calculated from the responses of 32 people who identified ransomware as the attack that had caused the greatest damage over the past three years and confirmed the length of the interruption. Asahi Group, for example, processed orders and shipments manually after an attack in September last year and did not resume computerized operations at its major subsidiaries until early December. Restoring normal logistics operations, including delivery lead times, took until February this year. In the meantime, Asahi Breweries’ revenue in the fourth quarter of last year fell to the low-80% range of its year-earlier level, while Asahi Soft Drinks’ revenue dropped to around 70%. Lingering logistics disruptions meant sales took time to recover even after computerized operations resumed.
When recovery costs compound falling revenue, investment needed for growth inevitably suffers. Companies must prioritize funding and staff for investigating how attackers gained access, restoring data and rebuilding systems. In its analysis of the costs of cyber incidents, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) also highlighted the opportunity cost of diverting resources from revenue generation and productivity improvements to security responses. Affected companies must therefore cover recovery spending while their income is reduced by business interruptions. If personal data leaks also undermine customer trust, existing investments in digital services may struggle to deliver results. If customers become reluctant to provide information and reduce their use of online payments and reservations, for instance, companies’ plans to automate those tasks and ease staffing pressures can also be derailed.
Table 1. Cybersecurity Response Burdens on Japanese Companies
| Category | Key Findings | Vulnerabilities and Response Burdens |
|---|---|---|
| Increase in Cyber Incidents | Reported incidents involving Japanese companies rose 48% this year, from 621 in the second quarter → 918 in the third quarter | Unpatched systems, configuration errors and vulnerabilities in external data integration functions |
| Spread of Damage Through Shared Services | A ransomware incident at IDC Frontier on the 7th of last month affected 495 corporate and local government facilities | Cascading damage when shared services are compromised Burden of managing accounts and access permissions linked to external services |
| Lack of In-House Expertise | Practice of outsourcing all work to systems integration firms Insufficient integration of IT into business strategy; CIO positions absent or nominal | Hinders development of in-house security capabilities Insufficient capacity to set investment priorities and lead incident responses |
| Shortage of Security Leaders | A Fastly survey found that 46% of Japanese companies had appointed a CISO | Weak oversight of security operations and decision-making structures |
| Delays in Replacing Legacy Systems | IDC analysis found that about 80% of large and midsize Japanese companies operate legacy systems The Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry also flagged slow transitions in its review in May last year | Increasing complexity and aging of existing systems Problems arising from delayed responses to the end of maintenance support |
Reliance on Outsourcing Leaves In-House Security Capabilities Lacking
Preventing further incidents is urgent if companies are to normalize operations and restore investment, but even fixing existing security flaws is proving difficult. According to cybersecurity firm Recorded Future, reported cyber incidents involving Japanese companies rose 48% this year, from 621 in the second quarter to 918 in the third quarter. Recorded Future identified systems without security updates, incorrect configurations and vulnerabilities in externally accessible data integration functions as major entry points. It warned in particular that attacks on services shared by multiple companies can cause cascading damage. A prominent example was the ransomware incident at cloud provider IDC Frontier on the 7th of last month, which affected 495 corporate and local government facilities. Corporate security work is becoming more complex as companies must both fix flaws in their own systems and manage accounts and access permissions connected to external services.
Observers also point out that companies have not developed sufficient in-house expertise to control the growing number of systems and services they must manage. Tetsutaro Uehara, a professor at Ritsumeikan University who advises the Japanese government on cybersecurity, said the practice of outsourcing all work to systems integration (SI) firms hinders the development of internal security capabilities. He explained that IT is not adequately incorporated into business strategy and that some companies either have only a nominal chief information officer (CIO) or none at all. Many companies do not even have an executive responsible for overseeing security. A survey by U.S. software company Fastly found that just 46% of Japanese companies had appointed a chief information security officer (CISO). This means that even when contractors perform technical work, companies lack internal leaders to set investment priorities and direct incident responses.
Delays in replacing legacy systems have further increased the response burden on companies already struggling with weak in-house expertise and decision-making structures. According to market research firm IDC, about 80% of large and midsize Japanese companies still operate legacy systems. The Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry has warned since 2018 about economic losses caused by the growing complexity and age of existing systems. Yet in a review in May last year, it again noted that transitions were slow and that problems were emerging one after another as companies postponed responding to the end of maintenance support. Some companies were found to lack even a feasible transition plan because they had failed to properly assess the difficulty of replacing existing systems. Planning alone can take years for large-scale systems, and even after work begins, newly discovered problems and stalled progress repeatedly push back replacement schedules.
Inadequate Training Slows Expansion of the Digital Workforce
A shortage of frontline personnel to handle maintenance and migration is also contributing to delays in replacing systems. Simply finding people to work on legacy systems is difficult. At the end of 2023, the Japanese government set a policy of doubling staffing at the National Center of Incident Readiness and Strategy for Cybersecurity (NISC) the following year. Last year, it also announced a target of increasing the number of nationally registered information security specialists from about 24,000 to 50,000 by 2030. Yet staffing shortages persist at companies. In a Japan Association of Corporate Executives survey reported by Jiji Press on the 12th, business leaders cited a shortage of security experts and the time required for recruitment and training as major challenges. Despite efforts to expand government organizations and increase the number of qualified specialists, the policies appear to have had insufficient impact on companies’ ability to secure the practitioners they need.
Staff shortages are also becoming entrenched across the broader digital sector that supplies security personnel. In the Information-technology Promotion Agency’s (IPA) “DX Trends 2025” survey, 85.1% of Japanese companies said they lacked personnel to drive digital transformation. The figure was 83.5% in the fiscal 2022 survey and 85.7% in fiscal 2023, showing no clear improvement over several years. Population decline and aging are also making recruitment more difficult, increasing the burden of retraining existing employees. According to last year’s OECD Employment Outlook, only 29% of workers aged 55–65 in Japan participated in education or training. Among workers aged 50 and older who use AI, just 25% had received relevant in-house training, indicating that opportunities to upgrade employees’ technical skills have not become sufficiently widespread.
Educational institutions training young specialists also face teacher shortages and enrollment limits. In materials for discussions on curriculum revisions released in September this year, the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology noted that expanding information education requires new expertise among teachers, but that some regions face difficulties in their teaching arrangements, including shortages of teachers responsible for the subject. Schools must expand information and technology education while securing teachers and improving their skills. At the university level, supplying talent in line with industry demand also remains a challenge. Materials on colleges of technology released by the ministry on the 16th assessed that undergraduate enrollment capacity for producing talent in science, engineering and digital fields remains insufficient. Expanding school education can ease corporate recruitment difficulties only after teachers are secured, departments reorganized and students educated, limiting how quickly the workforce can grow.
Unsupported PHP Versions Account for 70.1% of Usage
While the training of specialists remains slow, companies’ continued use of unsupported software is adding to their security burden. An April survey by GMO Prime Strategy of official, group and related websites belonging to Tokyo Stock Exchange-listed companies found that 70.1% of the 2,654 sites whose PHP versions could be identified were using versions that had reached the end of support. This meant that when a critical PHP vulnerability was disclosed last month, many sites already faced conditions that would make emergency fixes difficult. Replacing older versions requires changes to server environments and checks of compatibility with existing programs, so deferred routine maintenance increases the workload during incident responses. Companies with fewer staff are more likely to delay upgrades, creating a vicious cycle in which, once flaws are finally discovered, a limited workforce must also handle accumulated maintenance work.
Maintenance is further complicated by the fact that the websites companies must manage are scattered across multiple departments and affiliates. In the same survey, 85% of the approximately 25,000 sites that returned normal responses were related sites for recruitment, brands, individual services, affiliates and similar purposes. The survey firm concluded that management risks were concentrated in these sites. Strengthening security on the main corporate website does not eliminate the risk of a company-wide breach if poorly managed peripheral sites remain. Even identifying who operates each site and what technologies it uses, and assigning responsibility for updates, takes staff and time. Limited training for existing employees and delays in supplying new specialists also mean that higher budgets do not necessarily translate immediately into better response capabilities on the ground. Japanese companies now face having to pay all at once for long-deferred maintenance and workforce development while also absorbing losses from further attacks until that work is completed.
- Previous [Yuan Devaluation] China Raises Foreign-Currency Reserve Requirement to Curb Appreciation Despite Undervaluation Criticism, Complicating Calculations on Exports, Domestic Demand and De-dollarization
- Next “Domestic Demand Freezes, Export Opportunities Narrow”: China Faces a Structural Economic Crisis as Consumption Recovery Remains Elusive Despite Massive Stimulus and High-Tech Investment